What is a lawful basis?
A lawful basis is the legal justification for processing personal data for a particular purpose. Data protection laws do not only ask whether data is kept safely; they first ask whether the business may use it at all, for that purpose. Each purpose (sending an order update, a marketing broadcast, a login code, analysing support chats) needs its own basis, chosen before the processing starts and recorded so it can be shown later.
GDPR lists six in Article 6(1): consent; performance of a contract with the person; compliance with a legal obligation; protecting someone's vital interests; a task carried out in the public interest or in official authority; and legitimate interests, which need a balancing test against the person's rights. Special categories such as health data need an additional condition under Article 9. Consent must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, and the controller must be able to prove it.
India's DPDP Act is narrower. Section 4 allows processing only with consent or for one of the certain legitimate uses in section 7: data a person voluntarily provided for a specified purpose without objecting, certain state functions and benefits, legal duties to disclose information to the State, court orders, medical emergencies, epidemics and disasters, and employment. There is no open-ended legitimate-interests ground, so uses a GDPR team would justify with a balancing test usually need consent in India.
A lawful basis is a broader idea than an opt-in, which is only the consent route seen from the messaging side. A business messaging both Indians and Europeans often maps the same WhatsApp purpose to two different bases: a booking confirmation rests on contract under GDPR and on a voluntarily provided number under section 7(a) of the DPDP Act.
Key takeaways
- A lawful basis is the legal ground for one specific use of personal data; without one, processing is unlawful however well it is secured.
- GDPR offers six bases: consent, contract, legal obligation, vital interests, public task and legitimate interests.
- The DPDP Act offers only consent or a listed legitimate use; there is no general legitimate-interests ground.
- On WhatsApp, order updates usually rest on contract or a legitimate use, while marketing rests on consent in both regimes.
- Choose and record the basis per purpose before you start; switching bases afterwards is hard to justify.
Why the difference matters
Why does a lawful basis matter?
Picking the wrong basis is a compliance failure that no amount of encryption fixes, and it is easy to get wrong on WhatsApp, where transactional and promotional messages travel on the same number. A clear basis per message type tells the team which messages need an opt-in, which rights apply (an objection to marketing must stop it at once), and what the notice must say. It is also the first thing a regulator or the Data Protection Board will ask for.
A lawful basis: key facts and limits
- GDPR bases
- Six, Article 6(1)(a) to (f)
- DPDP Act grounds
- Consent (s.6) or certain legitimate uses (s.7)
- Legitimate interests
- GDPR only, after a balancing test
- Special categories
- GDPR Article 9 adds conditions (e.g. health data)
- Marketing messages
- Consent, in both regimes
- Burden of proof for consent
- On the business (GDPR Art. 7(1); DPDP s.6(10))
How does a lawful basis work?
- Step 1
List the purposes
Order and delivery updates, support replies, OTPs, marketing broadcasts, chat analytics, sharing data with a CRM: one row for each.
- Step 2
Identify whose data, and which law
People in the EU bring GDPR; people in India bring the DPDP Act. Many businesses need both columns for the same purpose.
- Step 3
Pick the basis per purpose
Contract or section 7(a) for what the customer asked for; consent for marketing; legal obligation only where a law requires the processing; legitimate interests only under GDPR, with a written assessment.
- Step 4
Match the notice and the rights
Consent needs a notice and an easy withdrawal; legitimate interests needs an objection route; contract needs neither consent nor objection handling, but still needs transparency.
- Step 5
Record it
Keep the basis and the reasoning for each purpose and, for consent, a consent record with timestamp and wording. Do not swap bases after the fact.
Example: One number, two laws, in Goa
A Goa homestay chain messages Indian and European guests from the same WhatsApp number. Booking confirmations and check-in instructions rest on contract for EU guests and on section 7(a) for Indian guests, who gave their numbers to receive them. Its off-season offers list needs consent from both groups, collected with an unticked box. A review found its support-chat analysis relied on legitimate interests: workable for EU guests with a documented assessment, but with no clear equivalent under the DPDP Act, so Indian guests' transcripts are now excluded unless the guest consents.
Common mix-ups
Common mistakes with a lawful basis
Using consent for everything
If the customer cannot refuse without losing the service, as with order updates, consent is not freely given. Use contract or section 7(a), and keep consent for optional uses such as marketing.
Importing legitimate interests into India
The DPDP Act has no balancing-test ground. Re-map every GDPR legitimate-interests purpose to consent or a section 7 use before applying it to Indian contacts.
Switching bases when consent is withdrawn
If a purpose relied on consent and the person withdraws, you cannot carry on under legitimate interests for the same purpose. Stop, and suppress the number.
Mixing purposes in one message
An order update with a promotional banner is partly marketing, and Meta treats mixed content as marketing too. Keep transactional messages free of offers so each keeps its own basis.
Lawful Basis FAQs
What lawful basis do I need for WhatsApp marketing?+
Can I send order updates on WhatsApp without consent?+
Does the DPDP Act have legitimate interests like GDPR?+
Can I change the lawful basis later?+
Rules of thumb
Best practices for a lawful basis
- Keep a one-page register: purpose, data, GDPR basis, DPDP ground, notice wording and retention.
- Write legitimate-interests assessments before processing starts, not after a complaint.
- Separate transactional and promotional templates so each message type maps to one basis.